Newsletter & Blog

If you are exploring in-home care for yourself or a loved one, you will probably see two roles come up again and again: Personal Care Aide (PCA) and Home Health Aide (HHA). They can look similar at first glance, but they support different needs, and choosing the right fit can make home feel safer and life feel easier.

This guide explains what each role typically does, how to decide based on real situations, and what questions to ask so you can move forward with confidence. If you want help choosing, RES Home Care’s In-Home Services team supports families across Nassau and Suffolk County.

Start Here: What You Need Help With Day to Day

A simple way to choose is to sort needs into two buckets:

• Daily routine support and supervision
• Hands-on personal care and health-related support

In many cases, a PCA is a great fit when the primary goal is safety, comfort, and help with daily routines. An HHA is often a better fit when there are mobility challenges, transfers, more hands-on personal care needs, or closer health observation is required.

Personal Care Aide (PCA): What They Help With

A Personal Care Aide typically focuses on day-to-day support that helps someone live safely and comfortably at home.

Common PCA support includes

• Companionship and emotional support
• Assistance with bathing, grooming, and dressing
• Light housekeeping and laundry
• Grocery shopping and meal preparation
• Medication reminders
• Socialization and community outings
• Escort to appointments
• Safety monitoring at home

When a PCA is often the best fit

• Your loved one is mostly independent but needs reminders, supervision, or help staying on a routine.
• You want support with meals, light home tasks, and companionship
• You are trying to reduce fall risk by having someone present during key parts of the day
• You need coverage for mornings, evenings, weekends, or short shifts when family cannot be there

Real-life example

Your mom is steady on her feet most days, but forgets meals, skips hydration, and has started leaving the stove on. A PCA can help keep her on a safer routine, prepare meals, and provide the steady presence that prevents small problems from turning into emergencies.

Home Health Aide (HHA): What They Help With

A Home Health Aide typically provides more hands-on support that can include basic health monitoring and assistance with more complex daily needs.

Common HHA support includes

• Vital sign monitoring
• Assistance with medical equipment
• Support with mobility and transfers
• Wound care support under RN supervision
• Personal hygiene care, including bathing, toileting, and feeding
• Household organization
• Specialized support for chronic conditions
• Ongoing health status reporting

When an HHA is often the best fit

• There are mobility challenges, transfers, ora  higher fall risk
• Your loved one needs more hands-on help with toileting, bathing, or feeding
• There is a chronic condition that requires closer observation and consistent reporting
• There is medical equipment involved, and you want trained help managing daily routines safely
• You want more structured monitoring and communication about changes in condition

Real-life example

Your dad recently came home after a hospital stay and is weaker than usual. He needs help getting in and out of bed, safer bathing support, and someone who can notice changes early and communicate concerns. An HHA can provide the extra level of hands-on support that makes staying home more realistic.

Where Nursing Services Fit In

In-home care is often strongest when it includes proper oversight and coordination. Nursing services can support the plan of care and help keep everyone aligned.

Nursing services may include

• RN assessments as required
• Initiating new cases and additional services
• Medication administration oversight
• Care planning and coordination with physicians
• Training and supervision of aides
• Crisis intervention and emergency response support

If you are unsure whether a PCA or HHA is right, a care planning conversation can clarify the safest starting point and prevent under-supporting a higher-risk situation.

PCA vs HHA: The Differences That Matter Most

Level of hands-on care

• PCA: Helps with daily routine support, companionship, and light household tasks
• HHA: Provides more hands-on personal care and basic health-related observation

Mobility and transfers

• PCA: Helps with safety and supervision during routine movement
• HHA: Better fit when transfers, balance concerns, or mobility limitations are present

Monitoring and reporting

• PCA: Observes daily changes and communicates concerns
• HHA: May include more structured observation, including vital signs and health-status reporting

Risk level

• PCA: Often ideal for stable routines and supportive supervision
• HHA: Often recommended when safety risks are higher, or needs are more complex

How to Choose in 5 Practical Questions

Use these questions as a quick decision guide.

1) Is mobility a concern?

• If walking, balance, or transfers are difficult, consider an HHA
• If mobility is mostly stable but supervision is needed, a PCA may be enough

2) How much hands-on personal care is needed?

• If bathing, toileting, or feeding requires significant assistance, an HHA is often the safer fit.
• If assistance is lighter and routine-based, a PCA may work well.

3) Are there chronic conditions that fluctuate?

• If there is a need for closer observation and consistent reporting, lean HHA
• If the goal is routine support and companionship, lean PCA

4) Is the main issue safety and supervision, or loneliness and routine?

• If isolation and day-to-day safety are the main concerns, a PCA can be an excellent match

5) Do you want a plan that can scale over time?

• Many families start with a lighter plan, then adjust as needs change
• A care team can help you build a plan that evolves smoothly as needs shift

Common Care Plans That Work Well for Families

You do not always have to choose one level of care forever. The best plan is the one that matches real life and reduces risk where it matters most.

Option A: Start with a PCA, then adjust

This works well when needs are emerging, and you want to support routine, nutrition, hydration, and safety first.

Option B: Use an HHA during high-need hours

Some families only need hands-on support during mornings, evenings, bathing routines, or transfer-heavy times of day.

Option C: Combine in-home support with structured programs

For some individuals, pairing in-home support with structured community-based services improves connection, consistency, and caregiver relief. If you are navigating funding options or waiver-related services, RES also explains support through its Aging at Home and waiver programs page.

Quick Answers Families Ask Before Starting In-Home Care

Can we start small and increase hours later?

Yes. Many care plans begin with a few visits per week, then increase as needs change. Starting small can still make a big difference if you target the highest-risk times of day.

How do we know if a PCA is not enough?

Common signs include increasing fall risk, difficulty with toileting or bathing, trouble with transfers, noticeable changes in condition, or growing caregiver strain. If safety becomes uncertain, it is time to reassess.

Is an HHA only for people coming home from the hospital?

No. HHAs can be helpful for chronic conditions, mobility limitations, and long-term personal care needs, not only short-term recovery.

What if we are unsure which role is right?

That is normal. A care planning conversation can review daily routines, mobility, health concerns, and goals, then recommend the safest fit.

Do you serve Nassau and Suffolk County?

Yes. RES Home Care supports clients across Nassau and Suffolk County on Long Island.

The Next Step for Your Family

Choosing between a PCA and an HHA is not about picking the most care. It is about picking the right care for safety, comfort, and independence.

If you are in Nassau or Suffolk County and want help building a plan that fits your family’s real schedule, reach out to RES Home Care to talk through needs and get matched with the right level of in-home support.

‍